What the oil is actually doing
Rust takes up more volume than the steel it came from, and it locks threads together. A penetrant gets into the microscopic gaps and along the thread, lowers friction at the contact points and helps the part break free when you apply torque. That is a loosening effect, not a cleaning one.
Some products do both a little
Makers describe a few products as rust-dissolving or rust-loosening. Treat those as maker claims, read the label for what the product is meant to do, and expect a stuck part to still need time and technique. We label maker statements as the maker's in our reviews.
What removes rust
- A wire brush or abrasive pad for surface rust
- A rust remover or converter made for the job, used as the label directs
- Replacing the part when the metal has pitted through
After the rust is dealt with
Once metal is clean and moving, a protective coating slows the return of rust on outdoor parts. Our rust-protection roundup compares the film-forming products on the site.