Two jobs, two formulas
A penetrating oil is judged by how well it gets into a tight, rusty gap. A lubricant is judged by how well it stays in the contact area and keeps surfaces from grinding. Those goals pull the formula in opposite directions: very thin fluids travel well and do not stay put, while thicker products stay put and do not travel.
The usual sequence
- Seized part: penetrating oil first, then time, then gentle torque.
- Once it moves: clean off the grime and spent penetrant.
- Then: grease for loaded parts, silicone or dry lube for light sliding parts, a protective coating for outdoor metal.
Where the lines blur
Plenty of cans are sold as multi-purpose products, and some penetrants leave a light film behind. That is fine for a quick fix, but for something that carries a load, such as a hinge pin or a chain, a purpose-made lubricant is the better long-term answer. Read the product label for the job it names.